Tag: queer

  • The (Laboring) Elephant in the Room

    The (Laboring) Elephant in the Room

    One of the major themes of Duke’s 7th annual Feminist Theory Workshop this weekend was  the condition of precarity. The initial conversation and configurations of the discussion of precarity revolved around the ethics of a privileged relation of the academic/scholar/researcher to an object of study that exists in precarity. However, it seemed to me, and many others, that the discussion of the ethics of such a position did not sufficiently acknowledge those of us at the workshop who were ourselves in positions of precarity—not because of our queerness but because of our labor relations to our universities.

    I am still amazed that the only time I heard the words “adjunct labor” during the workshop was when I brought them up in my seminar. A few months ago, at our annual literary disciplinary conference (MLA), adjunct labor and the state of graduate education were two of the most overwhelmingly present touchstones of conversation (along with the Digital Humanities) and were featured in Michael Bérubé’s Presidential Address. In literary studies, we refer to the collective status of PhD students and non-tenure track (NTT) faculty as  contingent labor. While the idea of “contingency” is useful in that it implies a relation between NTTers and the institutions that employ or do not employ them, “precarity” seems to resonate more with how I feel or experience this relation.  And the various affects of precarity were palpable within the small auditorium of the workshop.

    During the closing roundtable one brave soul “took a risk” (his words) in calling attention to the kinds of privilege that relate to established academics’ positions within institutions of higher learning. Graduate students, on the other hand, are living precarity, not (or not only) writing about it. The response in both situations (the seminar and the roundtable) was silence and diversion.  This continues to puzzle me. Many scholars in the room (not just those who had presented) have produced wonderful research on both precarity and the affects of precarity in relation to immigration, trauma, natural disasters, queerness, etc.  Why aren’t the frames of inquiry required in such research transferable to critiques of labor in our universities, disciplines, or departments? In subsequent conversations, one colleague suggested that the silence might be a result of helplessness, another guilt or complicity, another confusion or misunderstanding, another the inability to relate to our situation. As “brave soul” put it, “Where you are might never be mine.”  

     

     

  • Towards an Otherwhere

    Towards an Otherwhere

    Last night, at Duke’s Feminist Theory Workshop, Elizabeth Povinelli presented some of her recent work around geontologies. Both in the talk and in the q & a afterwards, there were often turns to her concept of “living otherwise”—that is, living in non-normative ways.  The phrase calls up for me early twentieth century writer Vita Sackville-West’s long poem The Land (1927) in which she describes the usefulness or even necessity for “reaching out towards an otherwhere.” Here’s the line with some context:

     And women still have memories of woods,

    Older than any personal memories;

    Writhen, primeval roots, though heads be fair,

    Like trees that fan the air with delicacies,

    With leaves and birds among the upper air,

    High, lifted canopies,

    Green and black fingers of the trees, dividing

    And reaching out towards an otherwhere,

    Threaded with birds and birds’ sweet sudden gliding.

    It is one of the most hauntingly beautiful passages of the poem. For “women,” Sackville-West seems to say, the “here” is not safe, not available, not fully inhabitable. Instead, the trees—which Sackville-West later associates with women through the figure of the dryad—search for an alternative place to inhabit. Not necessarily a safer place, but an “otherwhere” nonetheless.

    In Povinelli’s figuration of “living otherwise,” the attention is placed on practice, that is, the act of living or even the manner of living. In Sackville-West’s figuration, the attention is directed toward place. This idea of an “otherwhere” is incredibly provocative. What does it mean to reach toward a space which is not here? A place whose very existence as “other” depends on the existence and inhabitation of a “here” which might be conceptualized as a “normative” space? In many ways, this has been the work of many marginalized peoples, communities, and disciplines—to claim that which is “other-ed” (in ability studies and queer theory, for example) and in some cases to bring the “other” (-place, -people, -practice, etc.) into mainstream discourses and practices, with sometimes dubious results (e.g. gay marriage in the U.S.).

    What might be the meaningful differences between and emphasis on place versus an emphasis on practice? Perhaps the most obvious response to such a question is that they need not be mutually exclusive. It has been theorized that places are created by practice. And practices occur in both time and space. But I’m interested to hear what you think. Have we left theorizations of “space and place” behind us in the move to theories of practice? With what gains and what consequences?