In the fall of 2016, Carrie Robbins, the Curator at Bryn Mawr College, approached me about finding better ways to showcase student curated exhibitions of our over 50,000 artifacts and art objects. Students curate several exhibitions each year in temporary and borrowed spaces, but the labor that goes into these exhibitions often disappears with the objects when they’re returned to storage. Carrie wanted to find better ways to document and promote the work the students were producing.
To address this need, I wrote and was awarded a microgrant from The Association for Computers and the Humanities to collaborate with Craig Dietrich of Scalar, a scholarly digital publishing platform. Scalar has been designed primarily for media-rich digital scholarship. Through the grant, we sought to extend its applications to digital exhibitions. We achieved this by producing two new page layouts, the “scrolling path” and “people” layouts. Each of these layouts relies heavily on Scalar’s existing features and powerful flexibility. While the layouts were designed by Nathanael Roesch (Ph.D. Candidate in History of Art, Bryn Mawr College) with student curated exhibitions in mind, we hope they’ll be useful beyond digital exhibitions. To see a live version of the template, visit our test site. To see the template in action, check out The Tale of Genji. To try out the new templates on your own Scalar installation, visit the GitHub repo.
Over the course of the project, one of the biggest challenges we faced was conceptual, not technical. We knew that the end product, the template, had two important audiences. The first would be our Special Collections staff and student curators here at Bryn Mawr. For this audience, we knew we needed a local installation of Scalar that we could maintain and archive and that would appear under the university’s domain. We landed on setting up a Scalar install on our brand new digitalscholarship.brynmawr.edu domain. As part of the technical development process, we also began to develop a workflow for how we wanted students to engage with the template.
But these weren’t great solutions for the second audience, an amorphous potential public audience. We knew this audience would most likely be using the free hosted USC Scalar or a Scalar instance hosted at their own institutions. They likely wouldn’t be interested in creating books at digitalscholarship.brynmawr.edu/scalar/cool-book-name-here and even if they were, we weren’t in a position to host and support those books long term. And so we came up with a two-part solution, the first was realized through releasing the code with additional documentation on GitHub through an open GNU General Public License; the second is still aspirational—to release the new layouts on the free USC Scalar site. We’re working with the folks at Scalar to make this happen but in the meantime, folks with their own Scalar installs can try things out, mess things up, and build more things.
This second audience wasn’t quite as imaginary as I’m making it seem. Over the past year, I’ve had multiple folks ask me about how Scalar might be used for digital exhibitions. For the most part, I’d still recommend Omeka for digital exhibitions. Omeka is built to store as well as describe digital objects. Scalar isn’t really built to store objects. In fact, one of its strengths is that it insists objects live elsewhere on the web. It’s power is in linking and embedding digital objects (including objects from Omeka sites!), not in storing them. I do think Scalar is a great fit, however, for digital representations of physical exhibitions or for digital exhibitions in which the digital objects already have a safe, reliable, archivable home.
Further development and refinement of the Scalar Exhibition Template will continue after the grant’s conclusion. If you have questions about the template or suggestions about its improvement feel free to add them in the comments or tweet at me @aliciapeaker.
In 2011, the New York Public Library (NYPL) released 9,000 digitized restaurant menus with “delicious data” that had been “frozen as pixels,” making the menus difficult to search, index, and discover online. Along with the menus, the NYPL launched an interface that asked the public to help transcribe the thousands of menus and the hundreds of thousands of dishes. In only three months, the menus (and dishes) were fully transcribed.
The success of NYPL’s crowdsourced What’s on the Menu? demonstrates how enthusiastically public audiences respond to a well-defined project to which they can contribute through an expertly designed interface. While crowdsourcing has been used in the corporate world as a way to outsource tasks to nonemployees, it is increasingly being used in cultural and academic institutions for projects that seek to harness the energy and brainpower of the masses to complete specific tasks more quickly and inexpensively than would otherwise be possible. Many competing definitions of crowdsourcing exist, but perhaps one of the most helpful is offered by Enrique Estelles-Arolas and Fernando Gonzales-Ladron-de-Guevara: “A type of participative online activity in which an individual, an institution, a nonprofit organization, or company proposes to a group of individuals of varying knowledge, heterogeneity, and number, via a flexible open call, the voluntary undertaking of a task.”1
In some instances, academic institutions have taken the lead in developing platforms that facilitate crowdsourcing. Zooniverse, owned and operated by a partnership of eight academic, nonprofit, and corporate institutions, currently hosts thirty-three projects that ask participants to carry out a wide range of tasks—from analyzing cancer cells to classifying galaxies to identifying the seasons in photographs of landscapes. The resulting input has led to ninety-four published articles to date.
Crowdsourcing is particularly well suited to simple, repeatable tasks. The challenge often is to find ways for keeping participants engaged. Many classifications of crowdsourcing tasks have been proposed, but for academic and cultural institutions, the tasks may best be organized into four main categories:
Transcription
Supplementing Metadata
Collection Building & Curation
Identification & Provenance
Transcription.Many crowdsourcing projects and games seek to address the gap that still-lagging optical character recognition (OCR) technologies leave in the quality of their digital transcription capabilities. Most OCR software, for instance, is unable to convert handwriting or languages that use a non–Roman alphabet into machine-readable text. Ancient Lives, part of Zooniverse, teaches users how to identify and then transcribe ancient Greek text that appears on Egyptian papyri. Even more projects use crowdsourced transcription to transform handwritten documents into readable and mineable texts. For example, DIY History, built at the Iowa Digital Library, uses a customized version of Omeka to crowdsource the transcription of several of its collections of letters, diaries, and manuscripts.
Supplementing Metadata. Whereas text-based projects often require transcription, many cultural heritage institutions are increasingly facing the challenges of digitizing images and three-dimensional objects. These objects are virtually undiscoverable on the web without rich metadata. Recognizing this challenge, Dartmouth College’s Tiltfactor has partnered with several cultural institutions, including the British Library, to create a suite of competitive and collaborative games through which users provide metadata via a variety of tagging tasks. For instance, in Beanstalk, the user transcribes un-OCR-able words and fragments from digitized botanical texts. As the user provides transcriptions, the beanstalk grows higher and higher through various landscapes. Once the word has been transcribed multiple times in the same way by multiple users, the verified text is then returned to the library that holds the document and is added to its collection. As the game appeals to viewers: “Play Beanstalk, save scanned books from digital oblivion.”
Collection Building & Curation.Beyond projects that seek to make existing texts digitally discoverable, crowdsourcing is also being used to build and curate collections online. Crowdsourcing has been especially useful in documenting and providing a space for public and private responses to community tragedies. Projects like the September 11 Digital Archive, the Hurricane Digital Memory Bank, and Our Marathon: The Boston Bombing Digital Archive engage with members of the public to collaboratively build sites of collective cultural memory. In crowdsourcing collection building and curation, cultural institutions retain the responsibilities for preserving and providing access to their collections while transferring the assemblage of the content of those collections to community members.
Identification & Provenance. Crowdsourcing is frequently discussed in terms of the power of a massive and anonymous public. But crowdsourcing techniques are also being applied to smaller, more specialized audiences. For example, the Provenance Online Project, based at the Kislak Center for Special Collections, Rare Books, and Manuscripts at the University of Pennsylvania, relies on a community of experts outside of Pennsylvania to source and correct the provenance of individual books through the image-sharing platform Flickr.
Crowdsourcing remains an important strategy for many emerging digital projects that seek to build community around and through their projects. The best-built crowdsourcing tools make clear what each participant adds to the project and why each participant matters to the project as a whole. Some tools take these strategies a step further, connecting participants to each other through forums, collaborative tasks, and competitive scoreboards.
Perhaps the most-voiced concern about using crowdsourcing for scholarly projects is the quality of nonexperts’ contributions. To address this concern, the Maryland Institute for Technology in the Humanities is developing a transcription platform that clearly indicates the quality of available transcriptions from TheShelley-Godwin Archive. A red dot indicates an untranscribed document, yellow indicates a transcribed but unvetted document, and green indicates a vetted and approved transcription. As scholars increasingly build and contribute to crowdsourcing software, these technologies will become more reflective of the scholarly practices and concerns we share.
Crowdsourcing, particularly as it is deployed in the private sector, may also become exploitative when unpaid or underpaid labor replaces paid work. On the one hand, crowdsourcing is completely voluntary, at the discretion of the participant. On the other hand, relying on unpaid labor could work to dehumanize participants.2 True, many cultural heritage institutions, which are chronically underfunded in the United States, have a long history of engaging volunteer labor. The argument for such labor is often framed in terms of the “greater good” and engages participants’ desires to contribute to an institution whose mission they support.3
Crowdsourcing can open up access to previously inaccessible materials—but often in fragmented ways. Participants see snippets of text or a single letter, image, or document outside of the context of a collection. This fragmentation is frequently a result of trying to balance the need to lower barriers for participation with the overall goals of the project. Project designers often ask themselves questions such as the following: How much contextual information does the participant need to contribute meaningfully to the project? How do the goals of the project relate to the crowdsourcing efforts? How does the technology facilitate or hinder participation? If the crowdsourcing initiative is meant to increase buy-in of the project as a whole (as opposed to simply completing mundane tasks), more contextual information and cross-participant engagement are necessary.
Only in the last few years have advances in technology enabled the large-scale, asynchronous collaboration that can produce a project like the New York Public Library’s What’s on the Menu? And yet the spirit behind such a project reaches back much further. As Mia Ridge reminds us: “Technology has enabled crowdsourcing as we know it, but models for public participation in collection, research and observation pre-date it.”4 As crowdsourcing gains purchase in academic and cultural heritage sectors, new crowdsourcing tools and platforms will be transformed by scholars, artists, librarians, and curators who seek to engage with community members in meaningful ways. And these new platforms and modes of engagement will, in turn, transform the very shape of the scholarship and creative works that seek to engage communities.
Notes
Enrique Estelles-Arolas and Fernando Gonzalez-Ladron-de-Guevara, “Towards an Integrated Crowdsourcing Definition,” Journal of Information Science 38, no. 2 (April 2012), 197.
Aniket Kittur, Jeffrey V. Nickerson, Michael Bernstein, Elizabeth Gerber, Aaron Shaw, John Zimmerman, Matt Lease, and John Horton, “The Future of Crowd Work,” in Proceedings of the 2013 Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work (New York: ACM, 2013).
Mia Ridge, ed., Crowdsourcing Our Digital Heritage (Farnham, UK: Ashgate, 2014), 5.
The following is excerpted from a talk I gave at Middlebury College on February 24th, 2016 as part of the Carol Rifelj Faculty Lecture Series. It’s a literature talk which means major spoiler alerts! The data & code for many of the visualizations below are available here. This is very much a work-in-progress talk, and I welcome feedback, questions, suggestions, and collaborations!
Introduction
Early last year, the award-winning writer and scholar Robert Macfarlane published an article in The Guardian, intended as a preview to his book Landmarks, which was to be published later that week. In the article (and in the book), Macfarlane laments the loss of the language of landscapes, which he argues is being displaced by the language of technology. He cites the Oxford Junior Dictionary’s contentious decision to “cull” many “nature words” (Macfarlane n.p.) from its list, removing words like “adder, ash, beech, hazel, and willow” and replacing them with “attachment, blog, broadband, and chatroom.”
In response to this loss, Macfarlane works to collect and preserve hyper-local place words. He records words like “pirr”: “a light breath of wind, such as will make a cat’s paw on the water” and “smeuse”: an English dialect noun for “the gap in the base of a hedge made by the regular passage of a small animal”:
“Now I know the word ‘smeuse,’” Macfarlane writes, “I notice these signs of creaturely commute more often.”
These words are sometimes collected through casual conversations, but more frequently, he reports, through archival research, web searches, email conversations between scholars, and recorded oral histories. Technology is often characterized in opposition to the natural world (and sometimes with good reason). But it is clear from Macfarlane’s account of his own research that digital technology has not displaced the language of the natural world—it has recorded, transmitted, publicized, and preserved it.
Because, as Macfarlane’s book illustrates, our research methods have been deeply altered by digital technologies—it behooves us to increase the specificity of our understanding of technology. We are perhaps most familiar with “black box” technologies that separate user from code and mystify the processes through which new knowledge creation is facilitated. Further, it impedes knowledge creation and innovation—we learn to adapt our current methods or practices to new technologies rather than to create new technologies that better serve our practices and philosophies. And if there’s one thing you take away today it’s this—that the more humanists participate in the creation of their own research tools, the better those tools will be for our research.
As I’ve learned (sometimes quite painfully) through the process of this project, the more I understand about digital technologies the better my ability to create, adapt, and critique the limits of that technology. But perhaps more surprisingly, the more I learned about digital technologies, the better equipped I also was to push back on literary theory. What follows is both an account of my attempts to adapt concepts from ecology to literary texts via technology as well as reflections on what the process has revealed about the novels.
Project Beginnings
This project began with a question: How might we digitally represent the ecosystems of novels? At the time I was writing a dissertation about the visual and textual relationships between nationalism and specific engagements with the natural world (e.g. gardening, natural history, witchcraft, and herbalism) and at the same time tending a small garden I dug in some borrowed space in a friend’s lawn outside of Boston. There was something about the space of the garden that pulled my attention in a really different and corporeal way than the way I was engaging with representations of the natural world in texts. I was reading the poetry of the writer and gardener Vita Sackville-West–who is perhaps most famous in literary circles for her relationship with Virginia Woolf and in gardening circles for the creation of her “White” garden at Sissinghurst Castle in Kent and the gardening column she wrote for The Observer (now The Guardian) for many years. In her long poem The Garden, she writes of a gardener who:
…even in the interruption brought / By friends, [] will not stroll / At simple ease, but ever dart his eyes / Noticing faults, and feeling fingers twitch, / Eager to cut, to tie, correct promote”
Those of us who garden in public enough spaces likely recognize this characterization of the corporeal pull that keeps us in thrall to our gardens, even in the presence of visitors.
There was something about the very different corporeal and affective responses I was experiencing while gardening that had me thinking about the effectiveness of the different ways I was engaging with the natural world: from the close reading and deep analysis I was performing on texts about the natural world to produce my dissertation to my attempts to create the conditions to allow the plants in my garden to grow and thrive.
At the same time, I was beginning to engage with some of the digital methods emerging from the field of digital humanities—not for my dissertation, but for fun. And I found myself pulled into programming in a different but analogous way as I often get pulled into weeding.
Over time, my single question evolved into a series of questions:
I started to think about the possible consonances of close reading, programming, and gardening—all require some initial deep attention and planning. But in a garden, it’s often the letting go of control that produces the best results. So I started to wonder if I could create the conditions through which a novel’s ecological thumbprint or ecosystem could emerge? Or through which other readers might come into deeper contact with the novel and, ultimately, the natural world.
For several decades, close reading has been the primary method for producing the evidence with which literary arguments are made in scholarship and, especially, in our classrooms. More recently, Franco Moretti has controversially advocated for “distant reading” where the researcher “reads” thousands or even millions of texts algorithmically, looking for patterns and structures that span multiple texts. However, both closeness and distance can be dangerous positions to occupy in relation to our environment. To be too close is to lose sight of the larger systems in which we are imbricated. To be too distant is to remain outside, to see patterns without acknowledging one’s complicity within those systems.
By thinking beyond the binary of close and distant reading, I offer new modes of experiencing literatures of the environment that seek to connect readers and viewers not only to individual novels but also to thinking about and attending to the environment. My methods are derived from Jerome McGann and Lisa Samuels’s concept of “interpretive deformation” (115) in which “interpretation of works of imagination call[] for responsive works of imagination, not reflexive works of analysis” (109). McGann and Samuels explore the productive activities of deformation in a chapter of McGann’s book Radiant Textuality (2001). In the chapter, McGann and Samuels argue that “criticism (scholarship as well as interpretation) tends to imagine itself as an informative rather than deformative activity” (144).
They go on to argue that all interpretation is deformative, but that engaging explicitly in deformative procedures (such as reading a poem backwards, or reading only the verbs in a poem), foregrounds the subjectivity of the critic and her subsequent interpretation. Further, when deformation is preformed through criticism or—in my case, through computer programming and visualizations—“the reader [is put] in a highly idiosyncratic relation to the work” (McGann and Samuels 116). When readers occupy the space of this idiosyncratic relation, the reverberations of difference between their own point of view and the critic’s invite reflection.
Today you’re going to hear about some as yet early steps towards producing and theorizing these other kinds of engagement in the context of two novels: Thomas Hardy’s Tess of d’Urbervilles and Mary Webb’s Gone to Earth.
The Novels
Born in Dorset in the southwest of England in 1840, Hardy was a prolific novelist and poet whose life spanned the Victorian and Modern eras. At the beginning of his writing career, he primarily wrote novels—publishing more than a dozen between 1870 and 1895. Critics have long noted the importance of the natural world to Hardy’s novels.
Tess of the D’Urbervilles: A Pure Woman Faithfully Presented, published in 1891, is regarded by many as his best novel and by John Humma as “England’s if not the world’s most famous nature novel” (63). The early troubles of the eponymous protagonist double when she meets Alec D’Urberville, who relentlessly pursues her, resulting in a sexual assault that leaves Tess pregnant. Returning to her family, Tess gives birth to a child she names Sorrow who dies within weeks. A few years later, Tess seeks employment Talbothays dairy where she meets and falls in love with Angel Clare, a son of a minister, who she eventually marries. On the night of their wedding each confesses to having had sexual relations previous to the marriage. While Tess is accepting of Angel’s past, his worldview is completely shattered by Tess’s admission, and he leaves her (with some money) to start a farm in Brazil. Tess is driven further and further into financial difficulties. She is eventually discovered by Alec who again relentlessly pursues her until she agrees to live with him. When Angel returns from Brazil to reclaim Tess, Tess murders Alec and flees with Angel. Within a few days she is apprehended and hanged.
Mary Webb was a great admirer of Hardy’s, corresponding with him and dedicating her fourth novel Seven for a Secret to him, with his permission, in 1922. When Webb sent Hardy a presentation copy of the novel she included a note: “I do appreciate with intensity the rich beauty and majesty of your own interpretation of nature & humanity” (qtd. in Crawford & Crawford 97). And Hardy and Webb are often connected in terms of their understanding and treatment of the natural world.
A 1917 review in the New Statesman claimed that “Gone to Earth is the most impressive novel since Thomas Hardy gave us Tess of the D’Urbervilles” (qtd. in Crawford & Crawford 150). And indeed Gone to Earth might be considered a kind of rewriting of Tess. In the novel, a young Hazel Woodus lives with her ignorant and indifferent father and a menagerie of rescued animals (including a one-eyed cat and pet fox named, well “Foxy”). Webb writes that:
Like Tess, Hazel is relentlessly pursued by two male suitors: the first, a man named Reddin, is a country squire who lives in his decaying ancestral home with his misogynist manservant (who is obsessed with clipping a collection of yews into the shapes of swans). Edward Marston, the second suitor, is a minister new to the area who eventually marries Hazel against his mother’s wishes and brings Hazel to live with him in a state of unconsummated marriage. Reddin continues to pursue Hazel after her marriage. Catching her outside of her cottage one day, he assaults her and impregnates her, convincing her to run away with him back to his ancestral home. When Edward finds out where she is, he violently confronts Reddin and brings Hazel back to live with him, promising to raise the child as his own. Before the child is born, however, Hazel dies trying to protect Foxy from a pack of hounds driven by Reddin on a foxhunt.
Webb characterizes Hazel’s suitors as “Reddin the destroyer” and “Edward the savior” (final page of novel)—a description that also maps onto Tess where Alec is the destroyer and Angel the savior. And yet both Angel and Edward are failed saviours: in each novel neither the protagonist nor her child survives. The similarities in the plots and themes of the two novels make them ideal for comparison.
Before we get to the visualizations, I want to talk briefly about my digital methods and tools. I’m not going to go into great detail, but I’ve provided a list of resources and hyperlinks in the credits slide below and linked to many of them within the text.
Both of the texts I selected are in the public domain and freely available on Project Gutenberg. However, because no dataset existed that would adequately address my research questions, I needed to create my own structured data from these texts. I did this through a process of tagging every instance of a named character and reference to the natural world in both novels. Some of this I was able to automate through a tool called CATMA (Computer-Aided Textual Markup and Analysis) but a lot of it was done by hand.
This markup process is probably the most important step in this entire research project—and one that takes the most time and labor. The actual tagging can feel very tedious, but the intellectual work that goes into designing a markup schema is integral to the success of addressing the research questions. How the structure of the information is designed determines how the information can be used. For example, we are able to search library catalogues by author or by Library of Congress subject headings because book records are structured in such a way that specific fields like “author” correspond to specific pieces of information, like “Robert Frost.” If you searched for “Robert Frost” in a date field, the catalogue would (hopefully) return zero results. We take advantage of good and bad structured data all the time, but humanists are rarely involved in creating that data. The process of creating a markup schema surfaces individual and cultural ways of thinking and valuing concepts—in my case—novels and the natural world.
Like in many archival preservation projects, the most important and difficult question is not what to keep or what to tag but what to dispose of, what not to tag. This became painfully evident when—after attempting to mark up and categorize all features of landscapes at the beginning of this project—my schema became needlessly complex and my progress was very, very slow. Knowing that this is a forever iterative process, I eventually compromised by focusing only on “living” beings in the novel—the flora, fauna, and fungi—and only as they were directly named. I realized very quickly that significant references to the natural world emerged—particularly in Webb’s novel—not through direct references but through invocation, through metaphor and simile. For example, Hazel is described as “tawny and foxlike” (Ch. 1) and “sexless as a leaf” (Ch. 1). In a work of fiction, does it matter if the word “leaf” describes an actual feature of the fictional landscape or if it’s an example of figurative language? I ended up marking both.
Finally, I struggled with how to mark humans—clearly we are a part of the kingdom Fauna, but I wanted to be able to isolate the main characters of each novel and contextualize them in relation to the nonhuman others with whom they shared textual space (more on this later). As such, when you see the tag “Fauna” today, recognize that it is fauna absent of humans (something that will be fixed in later iterations).
Because the goal was not to make exact or precise comparisons, but rather to trace major connections among living beings and patterns across texts, I had to increase my tolerance for flattening some of the ambiguities I had been trained to highlight. For the remainder of this talk, I’m going to share four different sets of visualizations I’ve created based on this data that represent key concepts and patterns within the novels.
Absence & Presence
Early in my process, I wanted to get a visual overview of the notable presences and absences of the novel. I began by graphing every instance of a tag in the two novels in Tableau Public. Each vertical line is a tag in the novel and the horizontal axis is the novel from start to finish.
As you can see in the above visualization, Tess appears frequently throughout the majority of the novel. While Angel appears early on (when happening upon young women dancing in Tess’s village), his presence is “thickest” in the middle of the novel and spotty in the final third when he is in Brazil and no longer within the space of Tess’s world. Fauna is particularly dense in the first half of the novel, before the major turn, which is when Angel rejects Tess after their marriage. The density of these descriptions supports various ecocritical readings of the novel which portray Tess’s time at Talbothays Dairy (where she meets Angel) as the most idyllic (Meadowsong) or pastoral (Martell) of the novel. However, the presence of flora does not as neatly correspond to this characterization. Indeed, the most dense moments of flora in the novel occur nearer the end of the novel when Tess is being worked to the bone at a farm in Flintcomb-Ash where she digs swedes (rutabagas) and threshes wheat. These direct comparisons open up questions about how we have understood and characterized the pastoral mode in relation to the presence of nonhuman others.
Similar to Tess, Hazel as the protagonist is the most frequent tag in Gone to Earth. Hazel’s father, Abel, disappears from the novel almost entirely once Hazel has married Edward. Like Angel, Edward isn’t fleshed out as a character until well into the novel. In both novels, the antagonists (Alec and Reddin) occupy more of the narrative frame than the (failed) “saviors,” whose later entrances aren’t enough to counteract the damage done by the antagonists.
These visualizations were useful as exploratory tools, which helped me dig in deeper to the data and the novel. For example, many scholars have argued that Tess’s time at Talbothays dairy is the most pastoral section of the novel, dense with description of the natural world and eroticized connections between Tess and the environment she occupies. This graph suggests that the most organically dense section of the novel precedes her time at Talbothays and her assault. Which begs the question, which literary categories or concepts are objectively measurable? For instance are there measurable qualities of the pastoral mode that could be identified by an algorithm? Or is the pastoral a case of “you know it when you see it?”
Second, and paradoxically, the more a human is named in the novel, the more absent he might be. For instance, when Angel is away in Brazil, Tess thinks about him constantly, but we, as readers, are rarely transported to Brazil to hear from Angel. In other words, “Angel” is present in the text of the novel, but he is not present in the space of the fictional ecosystem that Tess occupies (while he’s in Brazil). Angel’s textual presence is invoked by Tess’s memory and desire. The presence and absence of Angel and Alec in this graph are greatly impacted by Tess’s attention: when Alec intrudes, she thinks less of Angel.
Botanical Barcodes
While these two sets of graphs around the two novels are interesting as separate artifacts, they are difficult to compare. By isolating the “flora” tags in each novel, and rescaling the horizontal axis (that is—the length of the novel—since Tess is nearly twice as long as Gone to Earth) a visual comparison becomes possible. The result is a kind of botanical barcode—one that will be unique and visually distinct for each novel.
These kinds of distillations of novels, or—to return to McGann & Samuel’s term—“deformations” of novels often experience brief bursts of popularity online. You may have seen Adam Calhoun’s visualizations of the punctuation of novels popping up in your social media and other feeds last week. Or Jaz Parkinson’s color signatures of novels a few years ago.
My botanical barcodes are particularly useful in understanding how mentions of the natural world (or in this case, the flora) fit within or help frame the narrative structure of the novel. For example, in Tess’s botanical barcode, mentions of flora appear most frequently at the beginning and end of the novel—like an establishing shot in a film.
From this visual, we might be able to conclude that the botanical world acts as a narrative frame which contains and somewhat overlaps with human drama. As human dramas increase, mentions of flora generally decrease. At the end of the novel, mentions of flora again increase, when Tess and Angel are reunited, fleeing together through the countryside.
In contrast, in Gone to Earth, flora appear most densely in the middle of the novel, and least frequently of all in the third section of the novel.
The dramatic contrast between the density and paucity of flora occurs after Reddin takes Hazel to live with him at Undern. Webb writes:
“It was almost as if the freemasonry of the green world was up in arms for Hazel. She had its blood in her veins, and shared with it the silent worship of freedom and beauty, and had now been plunged so deeply into human life that she was lost to it. […] So they stood and wept above her, and they foreswore her company for ever. She might regard the primrose eye to eye, but she would receive no dewy look of comprehension.”
Here the character who has had the most reciprocal relationship and empathy with the natural world is rejected by the “freemasonry of the green world.” The relationship becomes unidirectional. This shift results in fewer mentions of the natural world: as if only one half of a conversation is being reported. Without knowing the context of the novel, the increased absence of flora in the third section of the novel might be attributed to a displacement of a passive natural world by “human life.” However, such a reading denies the agency of, say, the primrose who withholds “comprehension” and whose active silence is a protest against Hazel’s abandonment. Active silence registers in the novel as textual absence and in the visuals as white space.
Like the punctuation & color visualizations, these botanical barcodes may be useful for noticing patterns across texts—for distant reading—but not for close reading. The punctuation charts were created by a neuroscientist (and data visualizer) & the color signatures by a graphic designer. Neither set were intended as tools for literary scholarship. I began playing with this possibility: could I produce something that was both publicly accessible and scholastically useful? With a few modifications of the original code, I began to address this:
Here you can see that running a cursor over the lines in the barcode causes a window to appear above the chart that provides the context of the mention of flora (with the flora highlighted in yellow) and the frequency with which this word appears in the novel.
This is far from perfect, but it is, I hope, a step towards creating tools to facilitate literary research—that let scholars and students move between close and distant readings. In future iterations of this visualization, I could, for instance, also compare the frequency with which an individual word appears in the entire corpus, which would help to identify and measure uniqueness and even, perhaps, add to Macfarlane’s lists of “nature words.”
Textual Habitats
Drawing on what I had learned from earlier visuals, I wanted to see where the natural world was at its densest. Around what or whom did instances of the natural world coalesce? In other words, I wanted to better understand the ecological context of the major human characters and be able to compare those contexts as a whole rather than to compare a single passage to another single passage (which is one way in which a close reading might happen).
In order to make these comparisons, I wrote a script that identified all of the “fauna” words that appeared within 120 characters—or the average length of a sentence in the novels—of, say, words tagged “Tess.” And I did this for each of the major characters (and for a few more general categories). I then graphed these moments of interspecies cohabitation as individual clusters.
Setting these individual clusters side by side in a kind of triptych emphasizes the variances between characters’ interactions with the natural world, or in this case, their interactions with fellow fauna. In looking at the triptych below, for Tess of the d’Urbervilles, we can see that Tess’s cluster is the most dense, Alec’s is the least dense, and Angel is somewhere in the middle.
Comparing the above triptych to the triptych of Reddin, Hazel, and Edward’s clusters below reveals that there are far fewer differences between the three main characters in Gone to Earth than in Tess. While Tess and Hazel both have the most connections to fauna, there is a striking difference between Alec’s and Reddin’s textual cohabitations with fauna.
You can explore the individual clusters at your leisure here, but in the interest of space, I’ll provide an example of how one particular cluster illuminates or was useful to me in better understanding Edward’s relationship to the natural world. While Angel’s views of both Tess and the natural world are colored by his Wordsworthian idealization (Lowe 57), Edward’s most frequent interactions with the natural world are a direct result of his relationship with Hazel.
As this short video shows, Edward’s most common fauna word is “bees.” Hazel’s father Abel keeps bees, so Edward is constantly among them as he courts her, but the narrator tells us that “Edward loathed bees in or out of boxes” (loc 171950 near fauna). Despite his “loathing” Edward courteously engages with both Abel and the bees—unlike Alec and his horses. Among the most common fauna words associated with Edward are “rabbit,” “fox,” and “cat”—the animals that Hazel brings with her after their marriage: “She and Foxy and the one-eyed cat, her rabbit, and the blackbird, were going to a country far from troublous things, to the peace of Edward’s love on the slope of God’s Little Mountain.” In this cluster, then, Edward’s varied relationships with different species are represented, but the force that created the conditions through which these relationships could occur—Hazel—is absent.
Similar to the botany barcodes, these clusters by themselves can’t tell us much about the kind of relationships each human has with various fauna. And this was really striking to me in one particular instance where both Reddin & Hazel had connections to the word “urchin” (a colloquial word for a hedgehog). The passage that both of these connections refer to is a section in which Reddin brings Hazel a hedgehog:
“Got something for you,’ he said, pulling at his pocket. ‘Oh! It’s an urchin!’ cried Hazel delightedly. Reddin began bruising and pulling at its spines with his gloved hands. ‘Dunna!’ cried Hazel. Reddin pulled and wrenched until at last the hedgehog screamed a thin, piercing wail.”
I began to address this issue by making contextual information from the novel available when the viewer clicks on a particular node. Even so, one of the major issues with these “clusters,” as I call them, is that they put humans at the center of the visualizations. If my goal is contextualize humans within the environments they inhabit, these visualizations do that but at the expense of visually overemphasizing the importance of human beings. The diagrams reinforce the very anthropocentrism I’m seeking to resist. To address this concern, I’ve begun playing with other kinds of visualizations including the network graphs below.
Whereas the clusters are a kind of moving snapshot of a given human’s habitat centered around that human, the graphs above represent the entire biosphere of the novel—that is, all the biotic beings that have at least one textual connection (measured by collocation) to another living being. The resulting visualizations are basically “spaghetti.” Illegible. Slow to render in a browser. Impossible to analyze in their current forms.
Each imperfect visualization fails in ways that provoke more and more interesting questions. And this is the space that, for the moment, is most exciting—to create, to make, to imagine, to question.
This post was originally published as part of the Council on Library and Information Resource’s (CLIR) blog Re:Thinking.
⌘+ S. We save almost without thinking about it. With the widespread adoption of word processing software, we’ve become thoroughly conditioned to save as we create. Not so with digital projects. There’s no easy equivalent to the ubiquitous “⌘ + S” that would automagically provide long-term preservation of digital objects and projects. As such, the urgent problems of preservation continue to require thoughtful conversations and deep planning.
On April 10 & 11th, scholars, librarians, archivists, and artists from 11 institutions spread across the northeast gathered at The Sterling and Francine Clark Art Institute in Williamstown, Massachusetts to weigh in on “Prospects for the Digital Humanities and the Arts.”
During the CLIR-sponsored colloquium, participants considered a wide range of challenges and opportunities facing higher education and cultural institutions committed to supporting digital research, scholarship, and pedagogy. The presentations and discussions collectively explored the life cycles of digital work—from the initial creation of digital objects, to the research and discovery process, to the production of scholarship, to the dissemination of that scholarship (both through publication and through pedagogy), to the preservation of that research.
While each of these stages is deserving of more than a single blog post, my notes from the colloquium return again and again to the challenges of preservation. The questions raised and explored by the group will sound familiar to many of us working in and with digital scholarship: What should be preserved? Where should it live? When should it be preserved? For how long? For whom? By whom? And in what form? Behind these questions lies an implicit belief in the intrinsic value of objects and in the ability of preservation processes to maintain an acceptable portion of that value.
Any deep discussion of preservation must also confront the anxiety about loss that often motivates and shapes preservation programs. Many of the projects and curricular activities showcased in the colloquium engaged both with fragile materials objects (including textiles, rare books, and film reels) and with digitized versions of those objects. Through discussion it became clear that we sometimes focus our attention on the fragility of material objects and forget that digital objects are also material and fragile, often prone to loss at a far higher rate than, for instance, paper, which has proved remarkably resilient. And it isn’t just the objects of our research that are deteriorating and becoming inaccessible, as Gerald Zahavi (University of Albany) reminded us, but also the hardware through which we once experienced those objects.
While conversations about preservation can be overwhelmed by a sense of loss, there was also a clear consensus in the group that some things must be protected from preservation. Many classroom activities and art objects are created to be ephemeral. To escape or even resist preservation. There’s a lot of room here, I think, for further dialogue and for thinking strategically about the dangers as well as necessities of preservation. (The history of the controversial practice of preserving natural habitats, for instance, might provide some provocative parallels and lessons.)
So who is responsible for preservation? Faculty members? Librarians? Archivists? All of the above? While the practice of digital scholarship can introduce students and scholars to preservation issues, the immediate challenges of creating new digital work can deflect attention away from preservation. And existing institutional structures and pressures can make planning for preservation incredibly difficult. While the pressures to produce digital scholarship increase, the timelines for production (especially the promotion and tenure processes) have not yet adjusted—or, as in the case of graduate education, have actually been shortened. With few exceptions, it takes more time to produce digital scholarship and digital projects than our institutions are accustomed to support. It takes more collaboration. It takes more expertise. All of these challenges often push preservation off the proverbial table.
And this is where I think libraries can and do play a critical role in facilitating the production and preservation of new digital scholarship. Libraries are increasingly housing centers for teaching and research, digital humanities programs, special collections and archives, and open access presses—as we heard from numerous participants at the colloquium. In many ways, libraries are at the center of the preservation challenge. So, what do libraries need in order to meet this challenge?
Few would consider the digital humanities an underground movement. And yet, much of what digital humanists do is perceived as inaccessible, buried beneath layers of technical expertise and politics. Riffing on the theme of the 2015 conference, this panel seeks both to “unearth” and to “earth” digital humanities practices in the context of environmental criticism. That is, we aim to bring to the surface existing environmentally-informed approaches to digital scholarship and to ground digital humanities in and through ecocritical perspectives. Topics of presentations or performances may include, but are not limited to:
Ecocritical digital humanities projects and tools
Environmental impacts of technology
Digital humanities and sustainability
Creative works that engage both the digital and the environmental
Digital archives of environmental literature
Text mining and other metaphors of unearthing in the digital humanities
Distant reading ecosystems or environments (fictional or real)
Ecomateriality of digital objects
Please send paper title, abstract (300 words), and CV to Alicia Peaker (apeaker[at]middlebury[dot]edu) by November 21st. Potential panelists will be notified by December 1st.
How can the digital humanities facilitate more direct engagement between academic researchers, students, and public audiences? At Our Marathon: The Boston Bombing Digital Archive, where I am currently Co-Director, we decided very early on that active public participation was integral to the success of the project. In addition to public engagement, we also wanted to create a digital archive that included robust metadata (or information about each of our objects) that would aid future researchers who wanted to work with our collections. It didn’t take long for us to settle on using Omeka.
Omeka is an open-source content management system (CMS) built at the Center for History and New Media at George Mason University that enables users to collect, annotate, and exhibit digital objects and artifacts. Omeka is a really powerful and useful tool for any digital humanist. Because Omeka is open-source, many digital humanities programs have developed features that you can add on (or “plug-in”) to Omeka to extend its uses. One of the most exciting plug-ins developed for Omeka is Neatline, a tool that helps students, researchers, and archivists create dynamic and rich digital exhibits. With the addition of two small apps, called SIMILE Timeline and Waypoints, Neatline can be used to set up multi-faceted digital exhibits that users can explore through time, space, or narrative. You can read more about Neatline here.
An example of a Neatline exhibit that uses the Simile widget.
Examples of Student-built Exhibits:
Undergraduate student project on the 1919 Molasses Flood in Boston (via Ryan Cordell)
Last month I attended my first DHSI on UVic’s idyllic campus. In just five days I became proficient in the notoriously difficult ArcGIS; moved my research several, big steps forward; and met some wonderful folks working on amazing projects.
The course I was enrolled in, “Geographical Information Systems (GIS) in the Digital Humanities,” asked attendees to bring their own data. Being a DH newbie, I had no idea what kind of data was out there or how to find it. I exchanged a few emails and then met with my university’s newly hired GIS expert about where to find data on my topic. She had some excellent recommendations for providing historical context data (UK Met Office for weather, Botanical Society of the British Isles for botany, and Natural England for wildlife populations, to name a few). But when I described my project in detail she looked at me and said, “Well, it sounds like we’re going to need to build your dataset from scratch.” I spent the next month trying to figure out what exactly a dataset really was and how to build one for my research on Edith Holden’s naturalist field books.
Here’s what I learned in the process:
Shape your research questions first. They may change, in fact they’re almost certain to change once you begin your research. But having a robust research question or set of questions before you begin will help temper the feelings of bewilderment often produced by beginning a dataset from scratch. I find Sonja Foss and William Waters’s list in Destination Dissertation (pg. 41) particularly useful in forming research questions – and so have my students.
Start simple. When I opened my excel spreadsheet and began creating columns for all the pieces of data I thought I wanted, I ended up with fifteen columns and a near-infinite, horizontal-scrolling problem. It was also taking me far too long to complete the dataset. So I simplified by narrowing my fields down to five, manageable columns: source, date, lat/long, type, and label. As you can see they are relatively basic kinds of information that are easily generalizable to other texts and projects.
Move beyond your doubts. Cutting back the number of columns was terrifying. What if I missed something important? What if my data wasn’t robust enough? What if it didn’t show me anything new? Would digital humanists scoff at my work? But then I realized that those questions, with a few substitutes, were pretty much the same doubts that I experienced when putting together my dissertation prospectus. They’re the same doubts that plague most graduate students and likely many early-career academics as well. Some of these questions are twisted versions of legitimate concerns academics should ask themselves about their research, but they are rarely useful and almost always harmful in the initial stages of a project. Shelve them for now and return to them (in their un-twisted forms) when you have a better sense of your project.
Failure can be fruitful. Perhaps even more fruitful in this kind of digital work than in “traditional” research. If your data doesn’t show you something you expect, it will likely show you something unexpected. In other words, the potential for new insights is even greater when working through failures – whether they be failures in the data design, in the data mining, or in the data presentation.
Don’t be afraid to ask for help. At whatever stages of the research you need it. I may have been stuck worrying that my data design wasn’t elaborate enough to constitute important research if I hadn’t asked a DH faculty member at my university what a dataset actually looked like. He shared a dataset with me, from a project he had completed, that was reassuringly elegant in its simplicity. It was an excel spreadsheet, with six columns of basic data (e.g. year of publication, place of publication, type of publication) that became a very useful model for my own project.
Savor the rewards. Maybe it’s the type-A in me coming out of the closet after years of unstructured academic research, but the gratification of seeing a spreadsheet full of beautiful data that I had collected felt even better than the satisfaction I experience after filling a page with writing. It’s even more rewarding when that data becomes something – whether that be evidence for your argument, items in a digital archive, or, in my case, a multi-layered map of Edith Holden’s field books.
Of course you don’t always have to build a dataset from scratch. There’s more data out there than you probably expect. Start with government agencies and societies organized around your topic or data need (e.g. The Royal Astronomical Society). In a larger project or with the right resources, you may be able to work with a developer or Computer Science experts to build an algorithm to collect digital data for you.
But for most of us, building a dataset often comes down to manually inputting columns and columns of data, gleaned from digitized or undigitized texts, into spreadsheets. While the work is often monotonous, the results can be invigorating. Here’s a static snapshot of the dynamic map my dataset has helped me create and a little foretaste of a future post:
One of the major themes of Duke’s 7th annual Feminist Theory Workshop this weekend was the condition of precarity. The initial conversation and configurations of the discussion of precarity revolved around the ethics of a privileged relation of the academic/scholar/researcher to an object of study that exists in precarity. However, it seemed to me, and many others, that the discussion of the ethics of such a position did not sufficiently acknowledge those of us at the workshop who were ourselves in positions of precarity—not because of our queerness but because of our labor relations to our universities.
I am still amazed that the only time I heard the words “adjunct labor” during the workshop was when I brought them up in my seminar. A few months ago, at our annual literary disciplinary conference (MLA), adjunct labor and the state of graduate education were two of the most overwhelmingly present touchstones of conversation (along with the Digital Humanities) and were featured in Michael Bérubé’s Presidential Address. In literary studies, we refer to the collective status of PhD students and non-tenure track (NTT) faculty as contingent labor. While the idea of “contingency” is useful in that it implies a relation between NTTers and the institutions that employ or do not employ them, “precarity” seems to resonate more with how I feel or experience this relation. And the various affects of precarity were palpable within the small auditorium of the workshop.
During the closing roundtable one brave soul “took a risk” (his words) in calling attention to the kinds of privilege that relate to established academics’ positions within institutions of higher learning. Graduate students, on the other hand, are living precarity, not (or not only) writing about it. The response in both situations (the seminar and the roundtable) was silence and diversion. This continues to puzzle me. Many scholars in the room (not just those who had presented) have produced wonderful research on both precarity and the affects of precarity in relation to immigration, trauma, natural disasters, queerness, etc. Why aren’t the frames of inquiry required in such research transferable to critiques of labor in our universities, disciplines, or departments? In subsequent conversations, one colleague suggested that the silence might be a result of helplessness, another guilt or complicity, another confusion or misunderstanding, another the inability to relate to our situation. As “brave soul” put it, “Where you are might never be mine.”
Last night, at Duke’s Feminist Theory Workshop, Elizabeth Povinelli presented some of her recent work around geontologies. Both in the talk and in the q & a afterwards, there were often turns to her concept of “living otherwise”—that is, living in non-normative ways. The phrase calls up for me early twentieth century writer Vita Sackville-West’s long poem The Land (1927) in which she describes the usefulness or even necessity for “reaching out towards an otherwhere.” Here’s the line with some context:
And women still have memories of woods,
Older than any personal memories;
Writhen, primeval roots, though heads be fair,
Like trees that fan the air with delicacies,
With leaves and birds among the upper air,
High, lifted canopies,
Green and black fingers of the trees, dividing
And reaching out towards an otherwhere,
Threaded with birds and birds’ sweet sudden gliding.
It is one of the most hauntingly beautiful passages of the poem. For “women,” Sackville-West seems to say, the “here” is not safe, not available, not fully inhabitable. Instead, the trees—which Sackville-West later associates with women through the figure of the dryad—search for an alternative place to inhabit. Not necessarily a safer place, but an “otherwhere” nonetheless.
In Povinelli’s figuration of “living otherwise,” the attention is placed on practice, that is, the act of living or even the manner of living. In Sackville-West’s figuration, the attention is directed toward place. This idea of an “otherwhere” is incredibly provocative. What does it mean to reach toward a space which is not here? A place whose very existence as “other” depends on the existence and inhabitation of a “here” which might be conceptualized as a “normative” space? In many ways, this has been the work of many marginalized peoples, communities, and disciplines—to claim that which is “other-ed” (in ability studies and queer theory, for example) and in some cases to bring the “other” (-place, -people, -practice, etc.) into mainstream discourses and practices, with sometimes dubious results (e.g. gay marriage in the U.S.).
What might be the meaningful differences between and emphasis on place versus an emphasis on practice? Perhaps the most obvious response to such a question is that they need not be mutually exclusive. It has been theorized that places are created by practice. And practices occur in both time and space. But I’m interested to hear what you think. Have we left theorizations of “space and place” behind us in the move to theories of practice? With what gains and what consequences?
I attended a recent MLA roundtable on Sustainability and Pedagogy that had me thinking (again) about the relationship between the environmental/ecocritical content some of us teach and the ways in which we teach that content. As eco-conscious teachers, it’s often difficult to help students find a place between the paralysis caused by feelings of helplessness about environmental degradation and the glorification of “Nature” as something pure and, therefore, worthy of preservation. My larger research project is interested in texts that exist in those in-betweens, particularly in the first half of the twentieth century.
This post is about a mixed-genre text, created by Edith Holden to chronicle, month by month, the activity she observed in the landscapes around Olton, Warwickshire. The collection, titled Nature Notes, 1906, weaves together folklore, poetry, journal entries, watercolors, botanic information, field notes, and more.
The book was never meant for publication, but in 1977 it was printed in facsimile under the new title The Country Diary of an Edwardian Lady. The change in title forebode its reception in the late twentieth century: it became a best seller, inspired a popular biography (by Ina Taylor, 1980), and spawned a 12-part TV miniseries. Reviews and spin-offs of Nature Notes have tended to focus on the text’s “nostalgic charm,” yet Holden’s text was intended, not as an ornamental coffee table book, but as a practical model for her students at Solihull School for Girls where she taught art from 1906-1909.
To a great extent, the teaching that occurs in this text is implicit, subtle, even circuitous. It is teaching by example or model, not by explicit instructions. “This is how you might go about it,” the text seems to offer.
The practice of learning from nature has a long history that continues into the twenty-first century (see biomimetics). Gardens, especially, have been used to teach children and young women how to become well-behaved members of society since at least the eighteenth century. Holden’s field books continue this tradition by expanding the didactic space of the garden to the “wild” spaces of uncultivated landscapes. As a result, these “wild” spaces no longer seem dangerous, threatening, or uncontrollable, but instead become associated with domestic(ating) practices like drawing and flower arrangement. It seems no accident that the pages of Holden’s text are populated with images of flowers, birds, and butterflies with only the occasional reptile, amphibian, or stinging insect.